Tellers Next Door is an intimate venue in Islip, New York, offering a refined setting for couples and hosts who value thoughtful service, exceptional food, and a relaxed but elevated atmosphere. Located beside Tellers: An American Chophouse, this private event space is designed for celebrations that feel personal, intentional, and guest focused.

For couples planning smaller weddings, wedding receptions, or meaningful private events on Long Island, the Tellers Next Door venue provides a distinctive alternative to traditional catering halls, prioritizing experience and connection over scale.

A Distinctive Long Island Venue by the Bohlsen Group

Tellers Next Door is part of the Bohlsen Group, a respected hospitality group known throughout Long Island for creating dining and event experiences rooted in quality, consistency, and care. The same attention to service and culinary execution that defines the group’s restaurants carries through every event hosted at this venue.

An established hospitality group supports the planning process, creating an organized and seamless experience with experienced staff guiding every detail from menu selection to event flow.

Event Spaces at Tellers Next Door

The Pavilion

The Pavilion serves as the larger of the venue’s two primary event spaces and commonly hosts wedding receptions and private celebrations. Its open layout and natural light support seated dinners and lively gatherings while maintaining an intimate, welcoming feel.

The Parlor

This space works especially well for couples who want a refined setting that still allows for movement, conversation, and an easy, social celebration flow.

The Parlor offers a more intimate indoor environment. It is ideal for smaller weddings, rehearsal dinners, engagement parties, and milestone celebrations. Featuring a dedicated bar and space for dining and conversation, it supports gatherings that feel warm and intentional.

For couples seeking a restaurant-style wedding experience with a strong emphasis on food and hospitality, the Parlor is a natural fit.

Weddings and Private Events at Tellers Next Door

While Tellers Next Door is not a traditional ballroom-style venue, it is well suited for intimate weddings and wedding receptions that prioritize connection and guest experience. Events hosted here tend to feel calm, well paced, and intentionally designed.

Couples who choose this venue often value exceptional food and beverage service. They also appreciate a guest-friendly layout with minimal transitions and an atmosphere that feels elevated without being formal or performative.

To see how a real wedding day unfolds in this space, explore Christine and Bill’s Tellers Next Door wedding. Their celebration highlights how the venue supports a heartfelt and seamless experience.

Why Couples Choose Tellers Next Door

Couples are drawn to the Tellers Next Door venue for its ability to balance elegance with ease. Rather than feeling like a production, celebrations here feel personal and comfortable for both the couple and their guests.

The venue appeals to couples who value intimate scale, thoughtful flow, and a culinary experience that elevates the entire day. It is especially appealing for those who want their celebration to feel refined while remaining deeply human and connected.

Photography at Tellers Next Door

From a photography perspective, Tellers Next Door supports natural, experience-driven storytelling. The venue’s scale allows moments to unfold organically, which is ideal for couples who value emotionally grounded imagery.

The Pavilion offers soft, even light throughout the event. The Parlor provides rich textures and intimate backdrops for candid moments and portraits. Because the space is thoughtfully designed, photography can happen efficiently without interrupting the flow of the celebration.

A Culinary Experience Guests Remember

One of the defining elements of hosting an event at Tellers Next Door is the culinary experience. Supported by the Bohlsen Group culinary team, menus reflect the same care and attention that have made Tellers: An American Chophouse a Long Island staple.

From plated dinners to cocktail-style receptions, food service feels seamless and intentional. This allows guests to enjoy the experience while couples remain present and relaxed.

Planning Considerations

The Tellers Next Door venue is best suited for intimate weddings, wedding receptions, rehearsal dinners, engagement parties, anniversary celebrations, and private milestone events.

Because the venue operates as part of an established restaurant group, planning tends to feel organized and efficient. Experienced staff guide menu selection, logistics, and service details.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tellers Next Door

Is Tellers Next Door suitable for weddings?

Yes. Tellers Next Door hosts intimate weddings and wedding receptions, particularly for couples who prefer a restaurant-style celebration or a smaller guest count.

Where is Tellers Next Door located?

Tellers Next Door is located in Islip, New York, adjacent to Tellers: An American Chophouse.

How many guests can the venue accommodate?

Capacity varies based on the space and event style. The Pavilion supports larger gatherings, while the Parlor is ideal for more intimate celebrations.

Is catering provided on site?

Yes. All events feature on-site catering provided by the Bohlsen Group culinary team.

Is Tellers Next Door good for rehearsal dinners or engagement parties?

Yes. The venue is especially well suited for rehearsal dinners, engagement celebrations, and private events where food and atmosphere are a priority.

Tellers Next Door Location Information

Tellers Next Door
605 Main Street
Islip, NY 11751
United States

Is Tellers Next Door Right for Your Celebration?

If you are planning an intimate wedding or private event and value hospitality, atmosphere, and experience, the Tellers Next Door venue is worth considering. Its thoughtfully designed spaces, exceptional cuisine, and strong service culture make it a standout option on Long Island.

If you are considering Tellers Next Door and want photography that reflects the emotion and experience of the day, Heritage House would be honored to document your celebration with care and intention. Reach out to begin the conversation.

About the Photographer

Stephen Mayo is the founder and lead photographer of Heritage House, a boutique wedding photography studio based in New York. Known for timeless, emotional imagery and legacy-driven storytelling, Stephen’s work has been featured in Sophisticated Weddings, Fearless Photographers, and trusted by couples and planners across the Tri-State area.